Money, Inflation, and Cryptocurrencies

Week 06

Vivaldo Mendes

Instituto Universitário de Lisboa (ISCTE-IUL)

October 26, 2026

1. What is Money?

Assets

  • To understand what money is all about, we need to know the difference between the different types of assets

Confusing money with wealth

  • It is very common to see people using the term “money” incorrectly. For example, in a recent episode we could hear:

“Cristiano Ronaldo plays for to the Portuguese national team only because he has a lot of money”.

  • What the person intended to say was “… because he has a lot of wealth”, or “because he is very rich”.

  • Wealth is the total value of all assets owned by a person or entity.

  • Money is a specific type of asset that is used as a medium of exchange, a store of value, and a unit of account.

Characteristics of money

Any asset that may be used as “money” must have the following characteristics:

  • Easy to carry, to store, and to transfer
  • Very liquid (easy to convert into Goods&Services)
  • Very divisible (easy to divide into smaller units)
  • Very cheap to use in transactions
  • Easily identifiable to be be used as fiat money (“curso forçado”)
  • Widely accepted by the population

The functions of money

  • The classical functions of money are:
    • Medium of exchange: Money is used to buy goods and services (i.e., to facilitate transactions).
    • Store of value): Money is used to store value (i.e., to save for future use).
    • Unit of account: Money is used to measure the value of goods and services (i.e., to provide a common denominator for the value of different goods and services).
  • There is another function of money that is usually overlooked:
    • A symbol of sovereignty: used to represent the the political independence of a country.
    • During the financial crisis of the Euro (2010–2016), the fact the UK had its own currency helped the country a lot
    • Spain, for example, went through a bad patch despite having a much lower Debt/GDP ratio than the UK

Measuring money

  • In the US, the aggregte we associate with “money” is named as “M2”

  • Money Supply (M2) is the total quantity of money supplied to the economy by the banking sector (central bank + commercial banks) and is given by: \[M2 = \text { Currency } + \text { Deposits } + \text { Money Market Mutual Funds }\]

  • Monetary Base (MB) is the total amount of money printed by the central bank that is outside of this bank’s vaults (its liabilities). \[ MB=\text { Currency }+ \text { Reserves } \]

  • M2 is much greater than MB and the link between the two aggregates is known as the Money Multiplier.

Measuring money

US Monetary Agregates: September 2025

Data collected from the Fed’s Money Stock Measures - H.6 Release

M2 Aggregates Billions of dollars
Currency 2324.2
Demand deposits 5648.9
Other liquid deposits 10987.3
M1 18870.3
Time Deposits 1083.3
Money Market Mutual Funds 2181.1
M2 22134.7

2. The Money Multiplier

The Money Multiplier

  • The derivation of the money multiplier is not required in this course.1

  • The money multiplier gives the following relationship: \[ M 2=\kappa \times M B \] where \(\kappa\) is called the money multiplier and \[ \kappa=\frac{\beta+1}{\beta+r r} \]

  • \(\beta=Currency/Deposits\)

  • \(rr=Reserves/Deposits\)

The Money Multiplier: Terribly Unstable


  • The money multiplier \((\kappa)\) is extremely unstable.
  • So, even if the central bank has a large control over the MB, it ends up with no control over the M2 because \(\kappa\) is terribly unstable.

R.I.P., Money Multiplier

“Well, when you and I studied economics a million years ago, M2 and monetary aggregates generally seemed to have a relationship to economic growth… that classic relationship between monetary aggregates and economic growth and the size of the economy, it just no longer holds… so something we have to unlearn, I guess.”

Jerome Powell, Federal Reserve Chair, Feb. 23, 2021, see here.

  • Nowadays, no central bank in a developed country pays any attention at all to the Money Multiplier.

  • It is a useless concept in modern macroeconomics: should be erased from textbooks!

  • But it is still there in all of them!

3. The Quantity Theory of Money (QTM)

The origins of the QTM

  • This theory was firstly presented by Martín de Azpilcueta (1536) to explain the Spanish high inflation during the XVI century.
  • That inflation was caused by the huge inflow of gold and silver from the Spanish colonies.
  • The Spanish Price Revolution was not only a novelty but it spread out to the rest of Western Europe.
  • The QTM is very simple to explain: \[M \times V = P \times Y\] \(Y\) is Goods&Services produced, \(P\) is the price level, \(M\) is the quantity of money supplied, \(V\) is the velocity of money circulation

QTM and inflation

  • Assume that the \(V\) is constant in the short term (pretty acceptable assumption)

  • Assume that \(Y\) is not affected by \(M\) nor \(V\) (pretty acceptable)

  • Then, the price level will be given by: \[P = (M \times V ) / Y \]

  • This equation can be written in terms of growth rates as:

\[\widehat{P} = \widehat{M} + \widehat{V} - \widehat{Y}\]

  • As in the short run, \(\widehat{V}=0\), and \(\widehat{Y}\) changes very litle, the rate of inflation will be mainly determined by the money growth rate \((\widehat{M})\).

Milton Friedman and Monetarism

  • Milton Friedman won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1976.
  • He was the most respected monetarist figure ever.
  • His most famous remark is this:

“Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon in the sense that it is and can be produced only by a more rapid increase in the quantity of money than in output.” page 24 in:

Friedman, M. (1970). Counter-Revolution in Monetary Theory. Wincott Memorial Lecture, Institute of Economic Affairs, Occasional paper 33.

How relevant is the QTM?

  • The QTM is very limited to explain inflation in a modern economy:

    • Prices do not depend only on money and GDP
    • It is true that GDP is not affected by monetary aggregates, but it is affected by monetary factors \((i)\) in all developed economies
    • The QTM has been easily refuted when considering the set of developed countries
  • However, the QTM has been vindicated when we consider huge increases in \(M\) in less-stable countries, like Zimbabwe, Venezuela, or Argentina.

  • So, if you think that “money” will be the solution to all our economic problems, think twice, be prudent.

  • Money, more money, more money and nothing else is a poor recipe for economic policy: GDP will not increase, inflation will.

QTM: Some evidence in the EuroZone

4. Hyperinflation

What is hyperinflation?

  • Hyperinflation is a situation where the rate of inflation reaches values so high that it becomes uncontrollable.
  • Famous cases of hyperinflation are: Germany in the 1920s, Zimbabwe in the 2010s, and Argentina in various occasions, among others.
  • In all cases of hyperinflation there is a common feature: the government resorts to printing money as the solution to serious problems.
  • Usually, these situations reflect a political structure at the verge of breaking down, rather than a clear and rational decision to print huge amounts of money to solve any problem at all.

Zimbabwe hyperinflation in the 2010s

A political regime at the verge of breaking down resorted to the money printer … as a miraculous solution

Germany hyperinflation in the 1920s

  • Germany lost the First World War and had to pay huge war reparations
  • The government made a series of stupid decisions
  • A political regime at the verge of breaking down resorted to the money printer … as a miraculous solution
  • A loaf of bread in Berlin that cost around 160 marks at the end of 1922 cost 200 billion marks by late 1923.

Germany hyperinflation in the 1920s

Argentina hyperinflation in the 2020s

A political regime at the verge of breaking down resorted to the money printer … as a miraculous solution

5. Cryptocurrencies

Cryptocurrencies: new and dangerous

“November 4, 2024, was America’s Hard Fork on digital assets. Since taking office, President Trump has righted the wrongs of his predecessor by fashioning the United States into a crypto superpower.”
U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, 30 July 2025

“I’ve always been deeply opposed to crypto, bitcoin, etc. The only true use case for it is criminals, drug traffickers … money laundering, tax avoidance. If I was the government, I’d close it down.”
JPMorganChase CEO Jamie Dimon, 6 December 2023, here

Cryptocurrencies: new and dangerous

  • The first cryptocurrency that appeared was the “Bitcoin” in 2009/2010
  • Until 2018, cryptocurrencies were like a fairy-tale: we had heard about it, but never bothered about it
  • Then in 2018, there was a monumental burst in crypto valuation
    • the price of Bitcoin increased by 2000%
  • Today, there are approximately 18000 actively tracked cryptoassets, but tens of millions of tokens have been created

Cryptocurrencies: new and dangerous

Current distribution of market share

A series of frauds, scandals, kidnappings

  • FTX. In 2022, the FTX bankruptcy sent Sam Bankman-Fried to prison for a fraud of more than 8 billion US dollars.

  • OneCoin (2014–2019): popularized as a “Bitcoin killer” by founder Ruja Ignatova, a Ponzi scheme with no actual blockchain, defrauding investors of roughly 4.4 billion US dollars. Ignatova vanished in 2017.

  • Bybit. On February 21, 2025, Bybit lost about 401,000 ETH, close to 1.5 billion US dollars.

  • Violent crime There is an increasing trend involving kidnapping related to crypto: NBC NEWS here

Crypto can not be “money”

  • Crypto transactions use pseudonymous: digital wallet addresses rather than real-world identities:
    • Most people do not want to have transactions with “secret” people
    • This creates a problem for general acceptability of crypto as money
  • Crypto valuation is terribly unstable:
    • Those that may accept crypto, convert the payment into fiat currency immediately
    • They must have someone immediately interested in buying those crypto assets
  • Small transactions with crypto cost much more than those with money:
    • 5% for a payment of $20 with crypto
    • 1.2% for a payment of $20, currently in the the USA using a debit card
  • Transactions with crypto take longer than those with traditional money instruments:
    • A debit card transaction is authorized almost instantly (in 2 to 3 seconds)
    • It takes several minutes using major crypto assets.

Crypto can not be “money”

So, what is crypto?

  • It is merely a speculative asset.

  • Performs only one function of money: store of value

  • It is used mainly by those who want to keep their identity secret when paying for something.

  • Relevance for monetary policy: none currently, none in the future.

  • More cryptocurrencies, more money, does not solve any real economic problems of modern societies.

    • But they may create some serious problems instead: hyperinflation, fraude, violent crime, etc.

Appendix: Derivation of the Money Multiplier

— Not part of the evaluation process —

Money Multiplier: Derivation

  • Money Supply (M2) and Monetary Base (MB) are defined as:

\[M 2=Cur+Dep \tag{1}\] \[M B=Cur+R \tag{2}\] \(Cur\) is “Currency”, \(\ Dep\) is “Deposits”, \(\ R\) is “Reserves”. From (1) and (2):

\[\frac{M 2}{M B}=\frac{Cur+Dep}{Cur+R} \tag{3}\]

  • Dividing the right hand side of eq. (3) by \(Dep\):

\[\frac{M 2}{M B}=\frac{Cur / Dep+ Dep / Dep}{Cur / Dep+R / Dep} \tag{4}\]

Money Multiplier: Derivation (continuation)

  • In eq.(4) we have \(Cur /Dep\), a ratio that is stable in the short-run: \(Cur / Dep=\beta\)

  • Moreover, the reserves requirement rate set by the central bank is given by: \[ R / Dep=rr \]

  • Therefore, eq. (4) can be simplified to: \[ \frac{M 2}{M B}=\frac{\beta+1}{\beta+r r} \]

  • Then: \[ M 2=\underbrace{\frac{\beta+1}{\beta+r r}}_{=\kappa} \times M B \]

  • \(\kappa\) is the money multiplier.

6. Readings

Readings

Read Chapter 5 “Money and Inflation” of the adopted textbook:

  • Frederic S. Mishkin (2015). Macroeconomics: Policy & Practice, Second Edition, Pearson Editors.

For the specific issue of “Cryptocurrencies” read sections 1, 3, and 4 of the paper:

  • Stephen G. Cecchetti and Kermit L. Schoenholtz (2025). Crypto, tokenisation, and the future of payments, CEPR Policy Insight 146, London. See here